Serious Injury

Legal battle finally proves fault of car driver in accident and results in £520,000 compensation for motorcyclist left with brain injury


Sarah Patten

Senior Solicitor and Manager of Serious Injury (Manchester)

5 min read time

A motorcyclist who suffered a brain injury in a road traffic accident has received a £520,000 compensation settlement – but only after a legal battle demonstrated a car driver had been at fault for his injuries.

The 53-year-old biker was in collision with a car which was pulling out of a pub car park in Bagshot, Surrey, causing him to fall from his bike, leaving him unconscious in the middle of the road.

The accident happening shortly after 11pm as he was driving home from his work as a restaurant manager and there were no witnesses to the road traffic accident other than the car driver, who initially denied having been in collision with the motorcyclist at all at the scene.

CCTV footage from a nearby hotel also initially proved inconclusive as to whether there was a collision and who was at fault.

The motorist faced no criminal action, despite eventually admitting in police interviews that the motorcyclist had in fact clipped the front offside of his vehicle.

CCTV footage did however show that the car driver moved his vehicle back into the pub car park less than two minutes after the accident, with the injured motorcyclist still unconscious and left in the middle of the road.

Serious injury specialist at Hudgell Solicitors, Sarah Patten, said the circumstances of the accident left the man in a difficult position given the lack of witnesses, and inconclusive CCTV.

The issue here was a lack of concrete evidence to support a compensation claim, given there had been insufficient evidence to prosecute the car driver and the lack of witnesses to provide statements.

I am sure that many firms may have opted on the side of caution with regards to his situation, in fear that a lot of time and money would be spent on his case for it not to be successful, especially in a no-win no fee scenario.

However, there was no suggestion at all that he had been driving anything but sensibly and within the law, and this accident had left him with a serious life-changing injury.

The circumstances of the accident, led us to believe that we could investigate a claim on the client’s behalf, and given the impact on his life, it was something we as a firm certainly believed we should do.

Subsequent investigations, which included the input of independent accident reconstruction experts and the analysis of skid marks on the road, showed the motorcyclist had been breaking prior to impact with the car and that he had been attempting to steer further to his offside to avoid an impact.

It also showed the motorcyclist had been upright until the point of impact with the car.

When the CCTV was further reviewed by the accident reconstruction expert using technology to further slow the footage frame by frame, there was evidence to suggest that a car had been moving forward at the time of impact.

It was only at the time of exchanging accident reconstruction expert opinions that the defendants admitted liability, as before this stage the case looked set to go all the way to court.

This suggested their expert had perhaps come to the same conclusion. The opinion of the reconstruction expert was crucial to the case, and to our client securing this settlement.

The legal claim alleged negligence from the car driver in that he failed to see the motorcyclist approaching as he left the junction, failed to keep any proper lookout and drove without due care and attention when the motorcyclist had right of way.

It was also alleged that he had therefore driven into the path of the motorcyclist, and failed to take appropriate action to avoid the collision.

In civil court cases such as personal injury claims, the law sides where the weight of evidence is greater, unlike criminal law, where guilt must be proven.

Our client, now 57, recieved a settlement which will help him adjust to life with a brain injury.

My client spent a period of time in intensive care and suffered a significant brain injury as a result of this accident.

He did make a good recovery, and to speak to him you would not immediately know he has suffered such a serious injury. However, it has had a huge impact on his life as he is no longer able to work as a restaurant manager, which he loved, and can no longer be the provider for his family that he was.

We were delighted that we were able to secure this substantial settlement for him and his family, as at one stage it looked as though he’d be left with nothing. This money has to support him and his family for the rest of his life.

Brain & Head Injury Specialists

Our solicitors have represented hundreds of clients across England and Wales who have suffered injuries ranging from mild head injuries to life-changing brain injuries, for which dedicated packages of long-term financial support, and physical and psychological treatment and care, are secured.

Please download a full copy of our Life Changing Injury Handbook.

Download guide

Life Changing Injury Handbook

Hudgell’s approach to serious injury. More than just legal support.


Related Advice

Related Advice

Expertise. Trust. Authority

View All
kerry gilespie serious injury podcast cover image hudgell solicitors

Serious Injury

Serious Injury Compensation Claims with solicitor Kerry Gillespie & Keith Phillips Around three million people in the UK are injured in accidents each year. If you’ve been left with a serious injury that was not your fault you may be entitled to compensation. Listen to specialist serious injury lawyer Kerry Gillespie explain why getting the […]

Personal Injury/Brain Injury

Personal Injury/Brain Injury

Brain Injury Compensation Claims with serious injury solicitor Samuel McFadyen & Keith Phillips Around 350,000 people in the UK are admitted to hospital each year with a brain injury. Many are caused by road accidents, accidents at work and even criminal assaults. Samuel McFadyen, a specialist serious injury lawyer, explains how compensation can be claimed, […]

legal forms being signed by clients in an office

What is a Grant of Representation and why are they important in compensation claims?

Making a medical negligence or a fatal accident compensation claim following the loss of a loved one can be a difficult experience for families. The sudden and unexpected loss of a loved one can be devastating and the litigation process can be daunting, but at Hudgell Solicitors part of our role as experienced clinical negligence […]

5 min read time

Related News

Related News
View All
person in a wheelchair

Spinal cord rehabilitation programmes need to be at the heart of a patient’s recovery plan to help them overcome everyday challenges

There are an estimated 50,000 people in the UK living with a spinal cord injury and each year around 2,500 people are newly injured. Spinal injuries can have a significant impact on an individual’s life. Trauma often causes some degree of paralysis which can require life-long care, support and rehabilitation. Spinal cord injuries can be caused […]

3 min read time
Untitled design (1)

‘Hudgells didn’t just help me after injury, but joined my journey to a new life helping others’

Robert Keane says the positive impact Hudgell Solicitors has had on his life has been ‘breath-taking’ – from securing a substantial damages award to compensate him for his life-changing injury to offering life-changing advice and ongoing support. For three years after his legal case was closed and damages secured, having being left wheelchair bound following […]

5 min read time
Start my claim